Malcolm Shaw

Malcolm Shaw
◆ What The Cryptid? News Network · Personnel File ◆
Malcolm Shaw
Senior Features Journalist
Folklore Correspondent
● On Desk WTC · WTCNN Asheville, NC · Since 2014
"She had no reason to lie. Several reasons not to tell me at all."
malcolmshaw@whatthecryptid.com
12k
Words — Hollow Creek Investigation
34
Items in Mara's SHAW (MISC) Folder
3
Notebooks. Third Is Fullest.
0
Times He Has Doubted Rico. This Week.
◆ About Malcolm Shaw

Malcolm Shaw came to paranormal journalism the way most serious people come to it — sideways, and somewhat against his original intentions. He studied folklore and oral history at Howard University, where he developed a genuine and abiding conviction that the stories communities tell about themselves — the legends, the warnings, the things the old people mention only once and never repeat — contain truths that straightforward documentation misses.

The Hollow Creek piece changed things. Malcolm had been assigned what his editor described as a straightforward community feature about a small Appalachian town's declining population. He filed, six weeks later, a 12,000-word investigation into a disappearance pattern spanning forty years, three generations of a single family, and a body of local folklore so internally consistent across unconnected witnesses that his editor read it twice and then called him and asked, quietly, whether he was all right. Malcolm said he was fine and that he thought there was a follow-up.

Where Rico charges and Mara maps and Daz tracks, Malcolm listens. He interviews witnesses that other journalists dismiss. He has a gift for the moment when people decide to tell the truth, and a journalist's instinct for what to do with it when they do.

The gullibility is, his colleagues agree, the one significant professional liability. Malcolm has reported, in good faith, on tunnel goblins that become aggressive during tax season, a specific species of Appalachian deer that can hold grudges across generations, and a creature Rico called a "marsh hesitator" which Malcolm spent forty minutes attempting to locate in three separate field guides before Daz, with visible reluctance, intervened.

He also currently believes the Mothman has a registered agent, because Rico told him last Tuesday. Nobody has corrected him yet. They're waiting to see where it goes.

◆ Known Details
Location
Asheville, NC. Deliberate choice. Three unfinished counties within driving distance.
The Archive
One room of his house. Visitors describe it as unsettling in a way they cannot immediately explain.
Vehicle
2009 Volvo V70, dark green. Boot contains evidence bag, spare notebooks, torch with unexplained battery life.
Coffee
Homemade, brought in thermos. Witnesses find the smell relaxing. He has considered whether this is useful data.
Ruth Calloway
Photograph on his desk. First Hollow Creek lead. Passed 2019. Malcolm was the only journalist at the funeral.
The Notebooks
Three. Interviews. Cross-reference. Third: red cover, fullest, never left on his desk. Name inside in pencil — "in case it needs to be returned."
◆ Covers
Investigation Sightings Local News Opinion
Avoids Breaking and List, which he considers "reductive." He has been assigned lists twice. Both ran over 3,000 words and included extensive historical footnotes.
Malcolm Shaw in the field
◆ Editorial Records ◆
Active Files & Ongoing Investigations
The following matters are documented in WTCNN editorial records. Folklore rarely survives without reason.
Foundation File · 2014 — Present
The Hollow Creek Investigation
Malcolm's foundational piece and the work that brought him to WTCNN. A 12,000-word investigation into a forty-year disappearance pattern across three generations of a single Appalachian family, cross-referenced against local folklore internally consistent across unconnected witnesses. The follow-up has been in progress since 2014. The file on his desk is currently four inches thick. Ruth Calloway gave him the first lead. He was the only journalist at her funeral.
Follow-Up: In Progress. Since 2014.
Active File · The Third Notebook
Things Witnesses Have Told Him
Malcolm's third notebook contains things witnesses have told him that he hasn't yet been able to place. It is the fullest of the three. Red cover. Name written inside in pencil — "in case it needs to be returned." The only notebook he does not leave on his desk. Evelyn Crowe said something in the break room once that Malcolm wrote in it immediately. Neither of them has repeated that conversation to anyone.
Fullest Notebook. Red Cover.
Ongoing · The Rico Problem
The Rico Problem
Malcolm has reported, in good faith, on tunnel goblins (aggressive during tax season), Appalachian deer (generational grudges), a Vermont sea shanty ordinance, reverse haunting, the marsh hesitator, and the registered agent of the Mothman. On each occasion he is gracious and professional when corrected. On each occasion he subsequently believes the next thing Rico tells him, usually within the same week. Two of Rico's obvious fabrications contained embedded accurate details. This has not improved the situation.
Ongoing. Marsh Hesitator Not Ruled Out.
Active File · Mara's Folder
SHAW (MISC)
A folder on Mara Vane's secure drive containing 34 items cross-referenced from Malcolm's published and unpublished work — interview offcuts, field notes mentioned in passing, a detail from a 2017 community profile Malcolm considered a dead end. Mara has not told Malcolm the folder exists. Three items in it currently appear under two separate active investigation categories and one that does not yet have a name.
34 Items. Malcolm Unaware.
Field File · Evidence Bag · March 2026
The Evidence Bag in the Volvo
A sealed evidence bag in the boot of Malcolm's car, containing material a witness in rural Tennessee described as "shed scales from something very large." Collected in March. Not yet submitted for analysis. Malcolm describes this as "giving the context time to develop," which is either a legitimate investigative methodology or a sign he is not entirely certain he wants to know the answer. Possibly both.
Collected March. Context Developing.
Personnel File · Greg · Personal
Greg (?) — Third Notebook
Malcolm is the only colleague who actively worries about Greg as a person. He has left three voicemails. Greg has not returned any of them. Malcolm noticed that Greg's last confirmed question to the archive team was unusually specific for a first-week intern. He has written this in the third notebook under a heading that currently reads: "Greg (?)". This has not been followed up officially.
Three Voicemails. No Reply.
◆ Editorial Note — Internal Use Only
The Thing He's Wrong About
Malcolm believes he is not gullible. He believes, specifically, that his willingness to take unusual claims seriously represents critical open-mindedness rather than credulity, and that colleagues who dismiss this are confusing rigour with scepticism. He is correct that they are different things. He is incorrect about which one he is demonstrating when Rico talks to him in a field. The gap between Malcolm's theoretical critical framework and his practical inability to apply it in real-time when Rico is being sincere is one of the network's more durable comedy engines, and it shows no signs of resolving. Mara has noted the gap in writing. Daz monitors for downstream consequences. Hal has tried to address it four times and stopped. It has not caused anything to be destroyed yet. It has caused Malcolm to spend forty minutes in a field in Vermont at 11pm looking for a creature Rico described as "about the size of a golden retriever but made of fog." He did not find it. He has not ruled it out.

◆ WTC Official Newsletter ◆

Join Dead Frequency

WTC's weekly paranormal dispatch. Free. Occasionally unsettling.

Breaking cryptid reports & field investigations
Ask Evelyn — paranormal advice column
Free Cryptid Field Guide on signup

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. WTC does not share subscriber data with entities.